Perjury in Ohio

You’ve probably heard the word perjury, likely in a courtroom drama or a news story about someone caught in a lie under oath. What it actually means in Ohio is narrower than most people assume. Not every false statement is perjury. People can misremember, contradict themselves, or give inaccurate information without committing this offense.

Perjury is a felony offense with specific elements, and a statement has to meet all of them before it qualifies. Knowing what those elements are is important for anyone facing these allegations in Dayton or elsewhere in Ohio.

What Is Perjury Under Ohio Law?

What Is Perjury Under Ohio Law?

Ohio’s perjury statute is Ohio Revised Code § 2921.11. Under that section, a person commits perjury when, in an official proceeding, they knowingly make a false statement under oath or affirmation, or knowingly swear or affirm that a false statement they previously made is true. In either case, the false statement must be material to the proceeding.

What Does the Prosecutor Have to Prove?

In a perjury prosecution, the state generally has to prove that:

  1. The accused acted in an official proceeding.
  2. The accused made a statement under oath or affirmation, or swore or affirmed that a previously made statement was true.
  3. The statement was false.
  4. The accused knew the statement was false.
  5. The false statement was material to the proceeding.

The state has to prove the required elements beyond a reasonable doubt. Ohio law also includes special proof rules for contradictory sworn statements and for evidence used to establish that a statement was false.

What Does “Material” Mean in a Perjury Case?

Under § 2921.11(B), a false statement is material if it can affect the course or outcome of the proceeding. The statute adds that this is true regardless of whether the statement itself would have been admissible as evidence.

Depending on the proceeding, examples of statements that could be material include:

  • Lying about where you were at the time of an alleged crime
  • Giving false testimony about who committed an offense

It is not a defense that the person mistakenly believed the false statement was unimportant. Materiality depends on the statement’s potential effect on the proceeding, not what the witness thought about its importance.

Where Can Perjury Occur?

The image most people have of perjury is a witness lying on the stand in a criminal jury trial. That is one setting, but the law is not limited to trials.

Under Ohio Revised Code § 2921.01, an “official proceeding” includes proceedings before legislative, judicial, administrative, or other government bodies or officials authorized to take evidence under oath. It can also include testimony or a deposition taken in connection with an official proceeding.

What Special Proof Rules Apply in Ohio Perjury Cases?

Ohio law addresses situations in which a person makes contradictory statements under oath about the same material fact. If the statements were made within the statute of limitations for perjury, the prosecution does not have to prove which statement was false. It must prove that one or the other was false.

The statute also limits how falsity can be proven. A person cannot be convicted of perjury when proof that the statement was false rests only on contradictory testimony from one person other than the defendant.

What Are the Penalties for Perjury in Ohio?

Perjury is a felony of the third degree in Ohio. If a court imposes prison for this offense, Ohio law generally allows terms of 9, 12, 18, 24, 30, or 36 months. A third-degree felony can also carry a fine of up to $10,000.

A felony conviction does not automatically require prison in every perjury case. Ohio law allows courts to consider community control sanctions in appropriate third-degree felony cases. The sentence will depend on the circumstances of the offense, the person’s criminal record, and Ohio’s felony sentencing rules.

A conviction can have effects beyond the sentence itself. A felony record may create difficulties with employment, housing, or other opportunities. Some professional licensing boards may also review a conviction involving dishonesty or false statements.

A perjury conviction may also be used to challenge a witness’s credibility in a later case, subject to Ohio’s Rules of Evidence.

What Defenses Can Be Raised Against a Perjury Charge?

Because the state has to prove the required elements beyond a reasonable doubt, a defense can focus on any element the prosecution cannot establish. The right approach depends on the facts.

Possible defenses include:

  • The statement was true: The most direct defense is that the statement the prosecution calls false was accurate. Documents, recordings, physical evidence, and other witnesses may support the defendant’s version of events.
  • The person did not know the statement was false: Perjury requires a knowingly false statement. Someone who misremembered, misunderstood a question, or made an honest mistake may have said something inaccurate without having the mental state the statute requires.
  • The statement was not material: Even a knowingly false statement is not perjury under § 2921.11 unless it was material. The defense may argue that the statement could not have affected the course or outcome of the proceeding.
  • The required oath or official-proceeding element is missing: Ohio’s perjury statute requires the relevant oath or affirmation to occur in an official proceeding. A casual or private lie does not become perjury merely because it is false. However, the statute also covers knowingly swearing or affirming in an official proceeding that an earlier false statement was true.

The right defense will depend on the circumstances surrounding the allegations and the evidence available.

Contact Suhre & Associates DUI and Criminal Defense Lawyers for a Free Case Review With a Dayton Criminal Defense Lawyer Today

Perjury is a serious felony allegation, but the state still has to prove each required element. At Suhre & Associates DUI and Criminal Defense Lawyers, our attorneys have 100+ years of combined experience and are ready to help you protect your rights and your future. 

If you’re facing a perjury charge, contact the firm today at (937) 531-0435 to schedule a free consultation with a Dayton criminal defense attorney to learn more and get started.